
On Spiritual Ignorance, Eternal Inheritance, and Whether Christians Truly Have Enemies
Does Loving an Enemy Change Who the Enemy Is?
When Jesus commands his followers to love their enemies (Matthew 5:43–48), we ordinarily understand the instruction as a requirement to treat hostile people with kindness. But perhaps the command raises a more fundamental question: Why must we regard someone who opposes us as an enemy in the first place? Someone may steal from us, persecute us, or even seek our destruction, but their behavior does not necessarily require us to adopt an opposing purpose toward them. There is a distinction between someone acting as our adversary and someone we regard as an enemy. Perhaps Jesus is doing more than regulating our behavior toward hostile people. Perhaps he is challenging the category itself.
Jesus grounds his command in the character of God, who provides sunlight and rain to both the righteous and the unrighteous (Matthew 5:44–45). Luke's parallel account goes further, connecting love for enemies with doing good without expecting repayment, receiving a great reward, and imitating the mercy of the Father (Luke 6:27–36). The teaching is not simply that hostility should be met with politeness. It challenges the assumption that another person's behavior determines the limits of our love. Their opposition may remain, but it need not dictate our ultimate purpose toward them.
Paul introduces another dimension when he declares that the Christian struggle is not against flesh and blood but against spiritual forces of evil (Ephesians 6:12). This does not mean people bear no responsibility for wrongdoing or that every aggressor is personally controlled by spiritual powers. It means human conflict exists within a larger spiritual reality. In 2 Timothy 2:24–26, Paul instructs believers to correct opponents gently, hoping they will receive repentance, recognize the truth, and escape the devil's snare. Although the immediate context concerns opponents of sound teaching, the principle suggests something significant: the person opposing us may also be someone who needs liberation. What if the person we consider an enemy is actually someone we should be trying to rescue?
Is Ignorance the Root of Sin?
This possibility becomes more compelling if sin itself is rooted in ignorance. Not ignorance in the sense of insufficient intelligence or education, but a failure to understand, believe, or properly value reality as God has established it. Pride involves an exaggerated assessment of our importance, wisdom, or authority. Greed attributes excessive value to temporary possessions. Envy interprets another person's blessings as a threat to our own well-being. Hatred reduces another human being, made in God's image, to an obstacle or object of contempt. Each involves a distorted understanding of ourselves, other people, or what is genuinely valuable. Could ignorance be the underlying condition that makes pride, greed, and hatred possible?
Scripture repeatedly associates sin with distorted understanding. Romans 1:18–25 describes people suppressing truth, becoming futile in their thinking, claiming wisdom while becoming foolish, and exchanging God's truth for a lie. Ephesians 4:17–19 connects alienation from God with ignorance, darkened understanding, and hardened hearts. Jesus teaches that knowing the truth brings freedom while describing those who practice sin as slaves to sin (John 8:31–36). Paul similarly calls believers to transformation through the renewal of their minds (Romans 12:2). Most strikingly, Paul says that the rulers of his age would not have crucified Christ had they understood God's wisdom (1 Corinthians 2:6–8). The identity of those rulers is debated, but the relationship between ignorance and evil is explicit. Peter likewise attributes the rejection of Jesus partly to ignorance while still calling those responsible to repentance (Acts 3:17–19).
The strongest objection is that Scripture also describes deliberate disobedience. James identifies sin in knowing what is right and failing to do it (James 4:17). Romans 7:15–19 portrays someone recognizing or desiring the good while acting contrary to it, although interpreters disagree about whose experience Paul is describing. Romans 1 emphasizes culpable suppression of truth, while Ephesians 4:18 associates ignorance with hardened hearts, suggesting that rebellion and ignorance may reinforce one another rather than always occurring in a fixed sequence. These passages challenge the claim that sin is merely a lack of information. Yet knowing a command is not necessarily the same as understanding its true significance. Someone may acknowledge that greed is wrong while behaving as though wealth is more valuable than obedience to God. That person possesses information but acts according to a false valuation of reality.
The deeper hypothesis, then, is that even deliberate sin involves a failure to fully comprehend, trust, or embrace what is ultimately true. This remains a theological inference rather than an explicit biblical doctrine. A serious objection is that defining complete understanding as whatever necessarily produces obedience risks making the argument circular. Scripture also speaks of the will, desires, grace, and the transforming work of the Spirit. Nevertheless, the distinction between intellectual knowledge and lived conviction is important. The father who cries out, "I believe; help my unbelief!" (Mark 9:24), demonstrates that belief and incomplete faith can coexist. Perhaps much of what we describe as a failure of self-control is more fundamentally a failure to understand and believe what God has promised.
The Inheritance That Changes the Calculation
Consider a simple illustration. Suppose someone offered a billion dollars to walk across a room. Assuming the offer were genuine and the walk involved no unusual danger, the decision would be obvious. The effort would seem insignificant compared with the reward. Now imagine the reward were ownership of the entire earth and everything upon it. A billion dollars would suddenly seem trivial. Yet Scripture describes an inheritance immeasurably greater than earthly possessions. Believers are called children of God and fellow heirs with Christ, with their future glory connected to sharing in his sufferings (Romans 8:16–18). They receive an unshakable kingdom (Hebrews 12:28), possess a heavenly citizenship (Philippians 3:20), and are promised life with God in his renewed creation (Revelation 21:1–7; 22:3–5). The promise is not private ownership of the universe but participation in God's eternal kingdom and communion with the Creator himself.
Even a googolplex of dollars would be an inadequate comparison because the inheritance is not merely an enormous quantity of wealth. It represents an entirely different order of value. Jesus compares the kingdom to treasure for which a man joyfully sells everything he possesses (Matthew 13:44). Moses rejected Egypt's treasures because he valued the promised reward more highly (Hebrews 11:24–26). Paul counted his former gains as losses because of the surpassing worth of knowing Christ (Philippians 3:7–8). These examples suggest that obedience is not always a struggle to suppress what we want. Sometimes it results from discovering that what we previously wanted was worth far less than we imagined.
The obvious objection is suffering. Walking across a room is easy; enduring persecution, violence, deprivation, or death is not. But increasing the cost without considering the magnitude of the promised inheritance changes the comparison. Paul declares that present suffering is not worthy of comparison with future glory (Romans 8:18) and describes temporary affliction in relation to an eternal weight of glory beyond comparison (2 Corinthians 4:17–18). Jesus experienced profound anguish before his crucifixion (Mark 14:33–36), yet Hebrews 12:2 describes him enduring the cross in view of the joy set before him. The argument is not that suffering becomes painless or morally insignificant. It is that suffering, however terrible, cannot ultimately outweigh what God promises. That hope must never become an excuse to minimize victims' suffering or neglect justice. The intensity of suffering and its comparative value in light of eternity are different questions.
If we genuinely understood the magnitude of that inheritance, how differently would we behave? Would temporary wealth, status, resentment, or gratification retain the same power over us? Perhaps we repeatedly choose lesser things because we have not fully comprehended the greater thing we profess to believe. First John 3:2–3 connects seeing Christ as he is with our final conformity to him and relates that hope to present purification. The passage does not establish that intellectual understanding alone eliminates sin, but it does connect seeing Christ with becoming like him. This raises a significant possibility: as our understanding of God becomes more complete, our perception of what is worth pursuing, possessing, or sacrificing may change accordingly.
What Can an Enemy Ultimately Take?
This understanding of inheritance fundamentally changes how we evaluate threats. We ordinarily call someone an enemy because that person threatens something we value. A thief threatens our possessions, a persecutor threatens our freedom, and a murderer threatens our earthly life. But Jesus instructs his followers to store treasure in heaven, beyond the reach of thieves (Matthew 6:19–21). He tells them not to fear persecutors who can kill the body but cannot kill the soul, directing ultimate fear toward God, who alone possesses authority over final judgment (Matthew 10:28). Hebrews 10:34 describes believers accepting the confiscation of their possessions because they knew they had something better and more enduring. Romans 8:35–39 declares that persecution, suffering, and death cannot separate believers from God's love in Christ.
These passages do not suggest that earthly losses are unimportant or that Christians cannot be seriously harmed. They establish that human power is limited. Someone may take our possessions without taking our eternal inheritance. Someone may destroy our reputation without determining our standing before God. Someone may even take our earthly life without possessing the authority to determine our eternal destiny. The person who threatens us may have the power to cause extraordinary suffering without having the power to take what we ultimately treasure.
If that is true, our relationship with the aggressor changes. We do not necessarily need that person's defeat to secure our own victory. We may need protection, justice, or restitution, but their destruction is not required for the fulfillment of God's promises. Indeed, the person attempting to take something temporary from us becomes someone to whom we desire to give something infinitely greater: the opportunity to know God and share in his kingdom. What initially appears to be a conflict between enemies may instead be a relationship between someone who possesses an eternal hope and someone who desperately needs to understand that same hope.
Confronting Evil Without Making People Our Enemies
None of this eliminates responsibility or the need to confront evil. A parent who prevents one child from harming another does not need to hate the aggressive child. The parent intervenes because the behavior is wrong, because the victim deserves protection, and because permitting the aggression would also harm the child committing it. The same principle applies to adults. We may need to establish boundaries, report wrongdoing, pursue legal remedies, or protect those in danger. Love does not require passivity, and forgiveness does not automatically restore trust. Someone need not be our enemy for their actions to require serious consequences.
Romans 12:17–21 instructs believers to reject personal vengeance, feed their enemies, and overcome evil with good. Paul does not command Christians to ignore evil; he commands them to overcome it. Romans 13:1–4 also recognizes a role for civil authority in responding to wrongdoing. Although Christian traditions differ over the legitimate use of force, the distinction between justice and revenge remains important. Justice seeks to protect the innocent, address wrongdoing, and prevent further harm. Revenge seeks suffering as repayment for suffering. Love adds another concern: whether the wrongdoer might repent and be restored. These purposes need not be contradictory.
Paul's own conversion illustrates why this distinction matters. Before encountering Christ, he persecuted Christians while believing that he was serving God (Acts 8:3; 9:1–2; 26:9–11). He later acknowledged acting ignorantly in unbelief and credited God's mercy with his transformation (1 Timothy 1:12–16). His sincerity did not make persecution righteous, and his conversion did not immediately erase the legitimate fears of Christians who remembered his conduct (Acts 9:26–28). Yet the persecutor became an apostle. His story demonstrates that someone can be genuinely dangerous, morally responsible, and profoundly mistaken while remaining capable of transformation. Titus 3:3–5 reminds believers that they, too, were once deceived and enslaved by destructive desires. Recognizing another person's spiritual blindness should therefore produce humility rather than superiority.
Jesus' prayer for those crucifying him provides a related example. Luke 23:34 records him asking the Father to forgive them because they do not know what they are doing, although some early manuscripts omit this sentence. The broader principle also appears when Stephen prays for those killing him (Acts 7:60). Romans 5:8–10 describes Christ dying for sinners and believers being reconciled to God while they were enemies. This does not establish that everyone hostile to God will ultimately be reconciled. It demonstrates that divine love initiates reconciliation while hostility still exists. The wrongdoer's behavior remains evil, but their destruction is not necessarily the outcome love desires.
Does Scripture Actually Eliminate Human Enemies?
The most serious objection to this argument is that Scripture explicitly recognizes human enemies. Jesus acknowledges that a person's enemies may belong to his own household (Matthew 10:36). Paul instructs Christians to feed their enemies (Romans 12:20). The Greek word translated enemy in Matthew 5:44 refers to someone hostile or opposed; it is not reserved for spiritual powers. The Old Testament also contains prayers for deliverance from human enemies and appeals for divine judgment, including difficult expressions such as Psalm 139:21–22. These passages prevent us from claiming that Scripture literally abolishes the existence of human enemies.
Yet there remains an important distinction between recognizing another person's hostility and adopting enmity as our own purpose. Someone can regard us as an enemy without requiring us to regard that person's destruction as necessary for our well-being. Jesus' parable of the Good Samaritan illustrates how mercy can transcend inherited social hostility (Luke 10:25–37). The injured traveler is not explicitly identified as Jewish, and the parable concerns neighbor-love rather than an identified personal enemy. Nevertheless, Jesus redirects attention from deciding who qualifies as a neighbor toward becoming a neighbor through mercy. Ephesians 2:14–16 similarly describes Christ overcoming hostility between Jews and Gentiles through reconciliation. Although that passage specifically concerns unity in Christ rather than every hostile relationship, it demonstrates that relationships once defined by opposition can be fundamentally transformed.
The most defensible conclusion is therefore not that the Bible denies human enemies, but that Jesus may be teaching Christians to transcend the category of enemy in their own understanding and purpose. Other people can remain adversaries through their conduct. They can oppose us, harm us, and refuse reconciliation. Yet their hostility does not require us to organize our response around hatred or revenge. The person acting against us may be someone whose behavior requires correction while also being someone whose salvation we genuinely desire.
When the Enemy Becomes Someone to Rescue
The argument rests upon three biblical themes that reinforce one another. First, Scripture connects sinful behavior with deception, distorted understanding, and spiritual captivity, raising the possibility that ignorance of divine reality underlies even pride and deliberate rebellion. Second, Scripture describes an eternal inheritance so extraordinary that earthly losses, however painful, cannot ultimately compare with it. Third, Jesus commands love for enemies because God's goodness and mercy extend beyond the boundaries of human reciprocity. Considered together, these teachings suggest that Christians have little reason to regard another human being as an enemy in the ultimate sense.
The ignorance hypothesis remains open to theological debate. Scripture does not explicitly establish that complete understanding necessarily produces obedience, and the relationship between knowledge, desire, and the will deserves further examination. Nor does Jesus explicitly state that loving enemies eliminates the category itself. But a theological argument need not be expressed in a single verse to deserve consideration. The question is whether the combined witness of Scripture supports the inference. In this case, it offers a substantial basis for distinguishing genuine opposition from the enmity we choose to maintain in response.
If the person harming us is spiritually deceived, then that person needs truth rather than our hatred. If our inheritance is secured in God, then that person cannot ultimately take what matters most. If God's love sought our reconciliation while we were enemies, then we have reason to seek reconciliation with those who oppose us. None of this excuses wrongdoing, eliminates boundaries, or diminishes suffering. It changes what we ultimately desire for the person responsible.
Perhaps Jesus' command to love our enemies is not merely an instruction to treat hostile people more kindly. Perhaps it is an invitation to understand God, ourselves, and other human beings so differently that the category of enemy begins to lose its meaning. The person who seeks to take something from us becomes someone to whom we desire to give something infinitely greater. We may still have adversaries, but we need not make their destruction our purpose. We can oppose their wrongdoing while desiring their redemption.
And if that is true, perhaps the most radical consequence of loving our enemies is that, from our side of the relationship, they gradually cease to be enemies at all.
Unless otherwise noted, Scripture references are from the English Standard Version (ESV).
This essay begins as conversations with AI, on my drive to work between Charlotte and Columbia. These are not friendly chats. I challenge everything the AI says, and I instruct it to disagree with me and push back on my arguments, so it challenges everything I say. Some of these conversations run for hours, and they force me to work through questions I might otherwise avoid. Afterward, I have the AI summarize the discussion and organize it into a structure. I work through that summary and write a rough draft. Then I use generative AI tools, such as ChatGPT and Claude, to correct, clean up, and revise the writing. This essay was produced with the help of generative AI. The questions it raises and the conclusions it reaches came out of that back-and-forth.

Comments
Post a Comment