On Spiritual Ignorance, Eternal Inheritance, and Whether Christians Truly Have Enemies Does Loving an Enemy Change Who the Enemy Is? When Jesus commands his followers to love their enemies (Matthew 5:43–48), we ordinarily understand the instruction as a requirement to treat hostile people with kindness. But perhaps the command raises a more fundamental question: Why must we regard someone who opposes us as an enemy in the first place? Someone may steal from us, persecute us, or even seek our destruction, but their behavior does not necessarily require us to adopt an opposing purpose toward them. There is a distinction between someone acting as our adversary and someone we regard as an enemy. Perhaps Jesus is doing more than regulating our behavior toward hostile people. Perhaps he is challenging the category itself.
Two men shove strangers to the ground. One intends to injure someone; the other is saving a life. A child pushes another child down. Is he bullying him, or is he inviting an excluded child into a game of roughhousing, finally treating him like everyone else? Someone shouts, “F**k you!” One person means it as an expression of hatred; another says the identical words to a friend who has accomplished something extraordinary, intending affectionate admiration (Ã la Roy Kent). Even reverence can look remarkably different across cultures. When I first brought my wife to a predominantly African American church, I warned her that the enthusiastic responses, shouting, and occasional crying during the sermon would be different from the quieter worship settings she knew. In that congregation, those responses communicated engagement and reverence, not disrespect. The same outward behavior can express opposite intentions. If an action can mean radically different things depending on its context, ho...